Tuesday, October 11, 2016

Nonverbal Communication Analysis No. 3721: The 2nd Presidential Debate - Donald Trump v. Hillary Clinton - The Handshake That Wasn't - Body Language and Emotional Intelligence (VIDEO, PHOTOS)

Throughout US history, presidential candidates have always shaken hands at the beginning of their debates. Sunday night history changed. The only handshake between Donald Trump and Hillary Clinton came once the second 2016 Presidential debate was completed.

When they walked on stage, it appears that neither candidate wanted to shake their opponent's hand - and they each had this mindset prior to the debate.

Donald Trump was the first to pivot toward the audience (signaling a "non-handshake" dynamic).

It would have been a moment indeed if one of them had extended their hand and the other refused to shake it. There was about 1.5 seconds (0:44 - 0:46) when Secretary Clinton did not swing her right arm while holding it slightly forward (while her left arm exhibited normal pendulum-like movement) while she was walking toward center stage - and configured her right hand just about six inches forward from the plane of her torso (appearing to be contemplating a handshake or in preparation to meet Mr. Trump's hand) - but this was not a full arm extension or a committed attempt at shaking hands.

What followed was a very emotionally uncomfortable moment.

Trump and Clinton then stared at each other.

Secretary Clinton was the first to turn away.

And while Clinton went to her chair - Mr. Trump walked around to the back of his chair.

Here both candidates made mistakes. Hillary Clinton leaned back on her chair while not fully sitting down. In the setting of a presidential debate this action made her look unsure of herself, not assertive and lacking in confidence (as further evidenced as she excessively preened the lower portion of her jacket).

Mr. Trump remains standing - which is a more alpha configuration, however he walks around in back of his chair - using the chair as a blocking device and insulating him from the camera, the audience and Secretary Clinton (which is considerably beta). This "feels" to him like he's standing behind a lectern/podium - a position in which he's much more emotionally comfortable.

Neither candidate should have sat down initially because the debate was to begin immediately and either could have been called on first. Sitting down while the other stays standing also appears acquiescing (significantly beta). Both candidates should have remained standing in front of their respective chair's until the first question was asked. Only then the other candidate should have sat down or remain standing near their chair (but not encroached into their opponents personal space as did Mr. Trump - See: Nonverbal Communication Analysis No. 3720: The 2nd Presidential Debate - Donald Trump v. Hillary Clinton)

See also:

Nonverbal Communication Analysis No. 3719: Donald Trump's "Apology" - Crisis Management, Body Language and Emotional Intelligence

Nonverbal Communication Analysis No. 3718: Donald Trump's "Access Hollywood" Hot Mic Video

Nonverbal Communication Analysis No. 3711: Vin Scully calls Kirk Gibson's legendary walk-off homer during Game 1 of the 1988 World Series

Nonverbal Communication Analysis No. 3708: Hillary Clinton v. Donald Trump - Presidential Debates - Part IV - Hillary's Email Anxiety

Nonverbal Communication Analysis No. 3703: Debate Advice for Hillary Clinton and Donald Trump

Nonverbal Communication Analysis No. 2135: Ronald Reagan in Nashua, New Hampshire - "I'm Paying for this Microphone Mr. Green!"

Nonverbal Communication Analysis No. 2379: Bill Clinton's Speech at the George W. Bush Presidential Library Opening Body Language of Former and Current President

Nonverbal Communication Analysis No. 3457: Chelsea Clinton refers to Bernie Sanders as "President Sanders"