On Tuesday 16 January, Dr. Ronnie Jackson gave a briefing at the White House regarding President Donald Trump's Health. A full body language analysis of Dr. Jackson would be extremely voluminous. What follows is a partial nonverbal analysis of that press conference emphasizing one particular nonverbal signal.
During 9:37 just after he says, "In summary, the President's overall health is excellent. His cardiac performance during his physical exam was very goodΩ " - Dr. Jackson displays one of many Forward Lip Purses.
He displays another Forward Lip Purse during13:59 as Hallie Jackson is asking, "... The President's personal doctor, memorably said, during the campaign that he would be the healthiest individual ever elected to the presidency, do you agree with that assessment?"
Another example is seen at 15:02, as Dr. Jackson is speaking (and stuttering) about how Sudafed was the etiology for the President's slurring of his words during a speech on 6 December 2017.
A Forward Lip Purse is a profoundly valuable nonverbal tell (not to confused with a lateral lip purse). It's an indication that those who display it are feeling an undisclosed disagreement and/or a clandestine plan. Moreover, forward lip pursing is only displayed by those who feel - at least in that specific context - they have a significant alpha status relative to others with whom they're currently interacting. Additionally, this signal is also an indication that they believe they have a high probability of success in implementing their plan.
Summary: At multiple times during his press conference on Tuesday, Dr. Ronny Jackson's nonverbal, verbal, and paralanguage behavior indicated deception. One prime example was his multiple displays of forward lip pursing - indicating an undisclosed disagreement and/or a clandestine plan.
On Tuesday, Homeland Security Secretary, Kirstjen Nielsen testified before the Senate Judiciary Committee. Senator Dick Durbin, who was also present in the now infamous meeting last Thursday in the Oval Office, questioned Secretary Nielsen. What follows is a partial nonverbal, verbal, and paralanguage analysis of their exchange.
DICK DURBIN (beginning at 2:34): You said on Fox News, "the President used strong language" - what was that strong language?
KIRSTJEN NIELSEN: Ahhh (pseudo-exasperated exhale), let's see - strong language - there Ω was - ahhh - I (stutter) apologies - I don't remember specific word - ahhh - what I was struck with frankly - as I'm sure you were as well - was just the general - ahhh profanity that was used in the room by almost everyone - ahhh and -
DICK DURBIN: Did you hear me use profanity?
KIRSTJEN NIELSEN: No sir, neither did I.
• Note the exhaling "Ahhh" Secretary Nielsen exhibits at the beginning of her answer (2:39 - 2:40) is hyperbolic/melodramatic - as if she were considering this question for the first time.
• The use of "let's see": "let's" is a form of diffusion of responsibility/lack of personal responsibility and is also what is known as "forced teaming" (de Becker) - and is very commonly used when manipulation/deception overlaps with patronizing behavior (Another similar phrase is, "How are we doing?" rather than, "How are you doing?").
• Repeating part of the question ("strong language") at the beginning of an answer - This is extremely commonly exhibited during deception - for it gives the liar additional time to formulate a lie.
• The sentence fragment, "I (stutter) apologies" - was a last-second avoidance of the phrase "I apologize" - representing a momentary slip and then a readjustment/distancing from ownership/responsibility. The word "Apologies" in this context is also a colloquial - detracting from the gravity of testifying before a Senate committee. Such informality has the effect of up-regulating her alpha status (and down-regulating Senator Durbin's) in this setting.
• "I don't remember the specific word" - The qualifying use of the word "specific" is itself a tremendous red flag for deception. Moreover, that Secretary Nielsen knew many other specifics - e.g., including that Senator
Durbin did not swear - and with the entire focus of the Oval Office
always on the President - it stretches any credulity to the extreme for her
to say she doesn't remember.
• The use of the word "frankly" is a profoundly valuable paralanguage tell. With rare exception, it betrays the presence of hidden agenda, insincerity, and deception.
• While many people in the Oval Office meeting last Thursday may have indeed used profanity, that's not the question Senator Durbin asked her. Additionally, her calling attention to others' behavior is a very common manipulation/propaganda technique commonly referred to as "Whataboutism" (aka "Whataboutery").
Secretary Nielson displays two rapid expressions of contempt during 2:42 (a microexpression just before she says, "was" and notated in the above dialog with the symbol Ω ) and during 2:43 (a subtle expression/near-microexpression simultaneous with "ahhh" - and highlighted in red font). The image immediately above captures the second of these two contempt displays. This signals Secretary Nielson's resent for being questioned before the Senate and/or by Senator Durbin.
At multiple times during this testimony, Secretary Nielsen smiled out-of-context. The first example shown in this analysis occurred during 2:47 in the above video, and, although initially partially suppressed, it crescendos throughout her sentence, "... I (stutter) apologies - I don't remember specific word - ahhh ..."
The second smiling out of context display in this exchange was also initially suppressed but then gave way to a full smile during 2:55 at the end of the sentence, "... what I was struck with frankly - as I'm sure you were as well - was just
the general - ahhh profanity that was used in the room by almost
everyone - ahhh and -".
The act of smiling during almost any testimony is ill-advised. Given Donald Trump's recent highly controversial Oval Office meeting - and the tremendous negative attention/ramifications it has garnered in the last several days - the best case scenario is that smiling in such contexts signals a smugness/arrogance. However, thin-slicing the Secretary's behavior further - such smiling out-of-context is a form of duping delight. This is particularly true here - as with both of these examples, her smiles were initially are suppressed - but then became fully expressed. Her presumed confidence/smugness was, in actuality, an ad-lib ruse/camouflage - a failed act of concealing her true emotions (not unlike coughing a split-second after flatulence).
Summary: Secretary Nielsen's verbal, nonverbal, and paralanguage behavior during this interview were extremely indicative of deception.
On Sunday, Donald Trump arrived at his International Golf Club in Florida. House Majority Leader, Kevin McCarthy was by his side as the President fielded questions from the Press. What follows is a partial nonverbal analysis of this exchange.
After proclaiming, "No, no, I'm not a racist, I am the least racist person you have ever (pause) interviewed, that I can tell you ...", and answering questions regarding North Korea - as well as DACA, and a possible government shutdown - Kevin McCarthy's nonverbal displays grew increasing noteworthy.
In this close crop of the above screen-grab image, the House Majority Leader's Central Forehead is Contracted (CFC) - and, along with his inner (medial) eyebrows - are elevated.
Crucially, any CFC must be interpreted in the context of simultaneous mouth configuration. As the corners of Representative McCarthy's mouth are down-turned, his overall facial expression projects Emotional Pain.
The camera angle doesn't pan-outward to a wider angle until the subject returned to DACA - but when it did we can see that Representative McCarthy was twisting his wedding ring. Immediately prior to our view of this, President Trump had been speaking about North Korea, a possible government shutdown, and denying he was racist.
Summary: Twisting one's ring - particularly a wedding ring - is a reliable symbol of anxiety. The conjunction of such ring rotation together with McCarthy's facial expression of emotional pain - telegraphs an amplified anxiety level. Representative McCarthy was anxious, beta, and emotionally uncomfortable standing next to President Trump.
Note: The original video has, since the original post, been removed from its online source. The images below however, were captured from this video.
Department of Homeland Security Secretary Kirstjen Nielsen was a guest on Fox News Sunday earlier today. What follows is a partial nonverbal analysis of a crucial portion of that interview.
With the exception of only two seconds (3:40 - 3:42), during the entire time Ms. Nielsen is on camera, her hands are in her lap and not gesturing (Illustrating). As the camera is directed at her face and upper torso - and we can see that her upper arms do not move at all. In this context, a lack of hand-arm gesturing is strongly correlative with anxiety. More specifically, keeping one's hands hidden (beneath a table, in one's pocket's, etc.) during a verbal denial is strongly indicative of deception.
Also during this entire segment, Ms. Nielsen's upper torso was blushing dramatically. Such vasodilation is highly correlative with anxiety - and more specifically - shame and embarrassment. It's signaling she feels "something is out of place".
Now note how much more her upper chest blushes - along with her face - just after she says, "... or a quota of Norway for example ..." (3:41).
CHRIS WALLACE (beginning during 0:33): Secretary, you were in that meeting in the Oval Office, did the President say that?
SECRETARY NIELSEN: I don't recall him saying that(slight pause) exact phrase, ah ...
During 0:39, as she says, "... saying that ...", Secretary Nielsen displays a Sincere Smile. This is a quintessential display of smiling out of context - and here, more specifically, this is known as "Duping Delight" (Ekman). This behavior is a nonverbal phenomenon signaling the presence of true joy experienced in the act of perpetrating a lie (the belief one has done so).
CHRIS WALLACE (beginning during 1:16): I, I don't understand, I, I'm goin' to just press back once on this subject. Ah, a, a, it seems to me - you were in the meeting when these comments were made - I can understand you either saying they said - or they were not said - it is pretty shocking language - and to say, "I don't recall", seems implausible. If the President of the United States used the word, "Blankhole", talking about countries in the Oval Office - or didn't say it - I would know.
SECRETARY NIELSEN: I, I [stuttering] I understand the question, it was an impassioned conversation, I don't recallthat specific phrase being used - that's all I can say about that.
During 1:49 another (less pronounced) example of duping delight is seen, as the Secretary says, "I don't recall that specific phrase being used - that's all I can say about that."
Two seconds later, during 1:51, the Secretary displays a Hard Swallow followed by a Prolonged Blink. These are not able to be properly observed on a still image - please watch the video to see this behavior in dynamic context.
Chris Wallace points out that by saying "I don't recall" (which Secretary Nielsen says twice) is "implausible" (his word). And, to thin-slice this from a statement analysis perspective, this phrase is extraordinarily rarely spoken in the context of truthfulness. Moreover, it's a red flag for deliberate efforts at plausible deniability.
In addition, Secretary Nielsen's use of "that exact phrase" and "that specific phrase" are additional statement analysis (paralanguage) qualifiers which, while are attempts at establishing wiggle room - aid in betraying her guilt.
Alisyn Camerota recently grew emotional during a broadcast while recounting the story of Ghanaian immigrant - Emmanuel Mensah.
Mensah, a 26-year-old US Army Private saved four people from a fire
in the Bronx before perishing on 28 December 2017. Only weeks before, on
21 September 2017, Private Mensah became a naturalized US citizen.
On
1 January 2018, Private Mensah was posthumously awarded the "Soldier's Medal" -
which is the Army's highest award for heroism occurring outside of combat.
These signals, particularly when clustered together, are indicative of sincere efforts at the suppression of tears (e.g., when a person is trying not to cry). Of course, there are some people who can "fake cry" (e.g., North Koreans who feign tears in the presence of Kim Jong-un) - but in such scenarios, these individuals would rarely display any of these individual signals of crying suppression - and essentially never do so in a clustered combination.
Summary: Ironically, the specific nonverbal manner in which Alisyn Camerota is suppressing her tears, indicates her tears and sadness are indeed sincere.
On Friday morning, via Twitter, President Trump denied making such a derogatory statement. Note Trump's lack of the word "I" in each of the first two sentences of denial. Such an omission of the singular first-person pronoun is a classic statement analysis pattern consistent with deception.
Senator Dick Durbin, who was in the Oval Office when the President allegedly made the statement regarding the incident. This is featured in the above video.
From a nonverbal behavior perspective, Senator Durbin sincerity quotient is high. More specifically - he shows no signals of deception.
Note the expression in the image immediately above - which was captured during 1:44 in the video (notated by Ω) as Senator Durbin says, "The most disheartening thing to me isΩ my belief that that was the first time words that hateful had been spoken in the Oval Office of the White House ..."
This expression, which was very evanescent (and thus classified as "microexpression") - is indicative of an amalgam of the emotions:
• Regret
• Frustration
• Sadness
Summary: Senator Dick Durban was in the Oval Office when President Donald Trump allegedly made his a statement referring to African countries and Haiti as "shithole countries". Senator Durbin's nonverbal, verbal, and paralanguage behavior in the above video are all consistent with sincerity. More specifically, Senator Durbin displayed no signals of deception.
Additionally, President Trump's lack of the use of the word, "I" in each of his sentences of Twitter denial are classic statement analysis findings consistent with deception.
On Wednesday, Donald Trump held a joint press conference with Norwegian Prime Minister Erna Solberg. What follows is a partial nonverbal analysis of a crucial portion of that event - when the President was asked about meeting with Robert Mueller.
JOHN ROBERTS (beginning at 6:25): Ah, thank you Mr. President. I also have a question for the Prime Minister, but if I could address the President first. Ah, Sarah brought up the Russia Investigation - Ahum, your legal team, sources have told us believes that in the next few weeks, the Special Council - Robert Mueller will ask for some sort of an interview with you. Your legal team believes it's part of wrapping up his investigation. Are you open to meeting with him, would you be willing to meet with him without condition or would you demand that a strict set of parameters be placed around any encounter between you and the special counsel?
DONALD TRUMP (beginning at 6:57): Well again John, Thah, there has been no collusion between the Trump campaign and Russians - or Trump and Russians, No collusion. Ah when I watch you interviewing all the people leaving their committees I mean, the Democrats are all running for office and they're trying to say this that,
As the President says, "Well again John, Thah (6:58), there has been no collusion between the Trump campaign and Russians - or Trump and Russians ..." - he displays a great example of a microexpression which betrays his anxiety and trepidation:
He looks down to his right (a quadrant where gaze is associated with sadness and regret) - as his central forehead contracts and elevates for a split second. This dynamic is somewhat blunted because the President's forehead has been treated with Botox - but it can be easily seen. Watch it at regular speed and again at 1/2 and even 1/4 speed.
The President Continues: ... but the bottom line they all say, 'There's no collusion' - and there is no collusion ∑.
At the very end of this sentence (during 7:17) Donald Trump takes a deep nasal inhalation (sniffing) and then immediately displays a "Loose Tongue Jut" indicative of the thought-emotions of, "I've been bad", "I've been caught" (Navarro).
DONALD TRUMP: .... And when you talk about interviews - ah - Hillary Clinton had an interview where she wasn't sworn-in, she wasn't given the oath, they didn't take notes, they didn't record, and it was done on the Fourth of July Weekend, ah, that's, perhaps, ridiculous, so a lot of people looked at that as being, ah, a very serious breach - and it really was. But again I'll speak to attorneys - I can only say this - there was absolutely no collusion - everybody knows it - every committee - I've been in office now for eleven months - for eleven months they've had this phony cloud - over this administration - over our government - and it has hurt our government - it does hurt our government - it's a Democrat hoax that was brought up as an excuse for losing an election - that frankly the democrats should have won because they have such a tremendous advantage in the Electoral College. So it was brought up for that reason. But it has been determined that there is no collusion - and by virtually everybody - so we'll see what happensΩ, ∆ .
At the very end of this paragraph (during 8:19), just after he says, "... so we'll see what happens ...", Donald Trump first displays a Regret expression.
JOHN ROBERTS: But again, will you, would you be open to a -
DONALD TRUMP: We'll see what happens, I mean, certainly I'll see what happens, but, ah, when they have no collusion, and nobody's found any collusion, ah, at any level, ah, it seems unlikely that you'd even have an interview.
Note how the President crosses his arms tightly with his hands hidden (8:19 - 8:28). From a body language perspective, this transmits the thought-emotions of defensiveness, fear, and close-mindedness.
Additionally, as pointed out in previous posts, this is part of an increasing pattern of behaviorcorrelated with a movement disorder caused by either a Central Nervous System disorder, Side-effect from a drug, and/or a Psychological condition.
Summary: Donald Trump's nonverbal behavior in this exchange indicates he is knowingly being deceptive with regards to Collusion with Russia.
Up until this moment, this fourteen-year-old girl had unaware of the extensive damage to her neighborhood from the California mudslides. Upon being rescued - and pulled from her collapsed home in Montecito, California - she was not prepared for the emotional impact of the seeing the flotsam and jetsam.
In this moment of realization, she displays a classic facial expression of surprise. Note the shape of her widely opened mouth - it's a vertically oriented ovoid. Additionally, none of her teeth are visible. Both of these features are components of sincere surprise. During feigned surprise - teeth are exposed and the opening of the mouth takes on a horizontal oval shape.
Simultaneously, her eyelids are also opened very widely - along with both elevated eyebrows and forehead.
True surprise is a very short-lived emotion, lasting only one to two seconds - as it's rapidly replaced with another emotion (commonly fear, anger, joy, sadness, embarrassment, etc.).
May we stand with the survivors as they recover as we grieve for those who have died in the California mudslides.
If you watched last Night's NCAA College Football Championship between the Georgia Bulldogs and the Alabama Crimson Tide, you witnessed a spectacular game. You may have also seen Donald Trump. In what for him, was a rare appearance at a sporting event, the President was on the field during the opening ceremonies.
Did you notice the President's unusual movements? During The Star Spangled Banner, with his feet planted, he continuously twisted/rotated his upper body. He also repeatedly patted his chest with his right hand. These abnormal movement behaviors are new for Donald Trump - and they're increasing in frequency.
This movement, however, is not a body language phenomenon - rather it's a manifestation of medical problem due to a:
But suppose for a moment, that these movements weren't due to a CNS problem or a Drug side effect - and, instead, these were pure nonverbal behaviors. In such a scenario, this out of context behavior would project disrespect and insincerity toward the National Anthem. An analogous interpersonal behavior would be, if during a hug - when a person, who had once maintained full palm-of-hand contact, would one day began to pat your back. This patting during a hug (if consistent) would signal a decrease in their level of affection toward you and a lack of sincerity in the hugging.
Summary: Donald Trump's repeated chest patting and torso twisting during the National Anthem is a behavior which has been increasing in the last several weeks/months and is indicative of a CNS disorder, a psychological condition, and/or a side effect from a drug.