Even Vladimir Putin sometimes slips and betrays his real feelings. Although the former KGB officer is highly skilled - he's only human. In this image from earlier this year, we see him in a relatively rare moment when his true emotions were revealed in public.
Biting one's upper lip - as with all body language displays - must always be interpreted in the context of the "nonverbal sentence" in which it appears.
Here we see the cluster of:
• Elevated Central Forehead Contraction (CFC)
• Both Eyebrows are Overall being Lowered
• Simultaneously, the Inner (Medial) Eyebrows are also being Elevated
• Partially Closed Upper Eyelids
• Flared Nostrils
• Tightened "Mustache Area"
• Biting Upper Lip
This is a classic array of Anxiety. Of particular note - are the juxtaposed tensions in his forehead. It may come as a surprise that the eyebrows as a unit can be lowered while simultaneously being pulled upward (here the inner eyebrows - along with his central forehead). Whenever two closely approximated (or even the same) tissues are being pulled in opposite directions - it's a signal of strong Emotional Dissonance. In this example, the Russian President's conscious mind doesn't want his feelings to show - and yet his underlying anxiety, for a few seconds, was captain of the ship..
Understandably, most people who are curious about body language, are particularly interested in lie detection. Yet, just as valuable, and perhaps even more so - is the ability to discern insincerity. For those individuals who are insincere may very well NOT be lying in that moment - but they're very likely to lie - lie often - and lie regarding profoundly
important matters.
This begs the Question: What are some nonverbal signals of insincerity?
Answer: There are many body language insincerity tells - but one of the most common and reliable is the overly-frequent contraction
of the forehead muscles.
Of course, we all use our foreheads to express our feelings - and we should - for it's an important part of normal human emotional display. However, when it's done too frequently - and especially when it's out of context - it's a signal that that person is trying too hard. They do not feel true conviction in their words alone. It's the nonverbal equivalent of using ten exclamation marks when only one is necessary.
Most all politicians are guilty of insincerity - and Ambassador Nikki Haley is but one of many (regardless of their political beliefs) who exemplifies this frequent forehead contraction pattern. Other professions where this nonverbal behavior is exceptionally common are - unskilled actors, pundits, sales professionals, and attorneys. Yet to overgeneralize is unwise - anyone, in any profession can be insincere.
Summary: Unmasking those individuals who show patterns of chronic insincerity is just as important as detecting deception. Overly-frequent contraction of the forehead muscles is one reliable and common insincerity display.
What follows is a partial nonverbal analysis of one portion of Ambassador Haley's Speech at the UN last week.
AMBASSADOR HALEY (beginning at 0:32): But we’ll be honest with you Ω When we make generous contributions to the UN, we also have a legitimate expectation that our goodwill is recognized and respected. When a nation is singled out for attack in this organization, that nation is disrespected. What’s more, that nation is asked to pay for the privilege of being disrespected.
During 0:34, immediately after she says, "... But we’ll be honest with you ...", Ambassador Haley makes an expression of Disgust. This is a relatively subtle-to-mild facial display of this emotion and notated by the symbol Ω.
Setting aside nonverbal behavior for a moment - from a Paralanguage/Statement Analysis perspective, whenever a person says, "to be honest with you" or in this example, with the forced teaming (de Becker) verbal modifier variant of "we'll" ("... we'll be honest with you ...") - there's an extremely high likelihood of overt deception and manipulation occurring.
A few moments later, during 0:57, just as Ambassador Haley says, "... that nation is asked to pay for the privilege of being disrespected. ...", she:
• Retracts her torso, head, and neck
• Contracts and Elevates the entire width of her forehead
• Actively partially closes both of her upper eyelids
Opposite movements of adjacent tissues - e.g., the upper eyelids moving down (partially closing) - while the nearby tissues of eyebrows and forehead are moving up - is an unnatural dynamic and a nonverbal red flag.
This nonverbal cluster expression dynamic projects an amalgam of:
Summary: During her speech to the UN on Thursday 21 December 2017, Ambassador Nikki Haley's nonverbal behavior projected the emotions of Disgust, Contempt, Arrogance, and Feigned Disbelief - toward any UN members who would disagree with President Trump's stance regarding the United States' recognition of Jerusalem as Israel's capital.
Kevin Spacey was the actor cast as J. Paul Getty in the just released film, All the Money in the World. Yet after multiple allegations of sexual assault were brought forth against Spacey, his character was replaced with actor Christopher Plummer - and the necessary scenes were re-filmed.
What follows is a partial nonverbal analysis of Michelle Williams (who plays Gail Harris, the primary protagonist) - and her feelings regarding Spacey within interview in the above video.
JOURNALIST (beginning at 1:11): Were you friends with Kevin Spacey, I mean - were you surprised by these accusations, revelations?
MICHELLE WILLIAMS: I- we had very little interaction Ω
As she says, "... interaction", and for about 2 seconds afterward (1:16 - 1:18), Ms. Williams scratches her nose with her right thumb. You'll also note that her forehead is contracted, her eyebrows are elevated, and her upper eyelids are opened slightly wider. Moreover, Michelle Williams sounded like a politician, because she did not answer the questions regarding any friendship with Kevin Spacey or whether she was surprised at the accusations.
This indirect verbal denial (a non-denial denial), coupled with her cluster of nonverbal behavior - particular the nose scratch timed as it was - is highly indicative of deception.
Now go back a few seconds, during 1:11 - 1:12, as the journalist asks his question. Michelle Williams is bouncing (extending and flexing) her legs. This is significant as a general signal of anxiety.
But look closer - where are Michelle's hands? They are beneath her left thigh. In this context, this strongly transmits emotions of a hesitancy to discuss and/or hesitancy to disclose. In the vast majority of her camera time shown here, her hands are in this same position - (except when she scratches her nose, and then only with her right hand - and it goes immediately back beneath her thigh).
Beginning at 3:34, Michelle Williams says, "I had felt like, 'here we go again', like it's all about - it's all about the - abuser - and that's the tyranny of abuse, that it's all about them, and we're all living in the aftermath of their actions."
As she says, "... tyranny of abuse, that it's...", Michelle Williams displays a snarl-like configuration (during 3:43 - 3:44, characterized by the contraction and elevation of her right mid-face) - which is an excellent example of a classic Contempt display.
Summary: Michelle Williams is a very accomplished actor. She's been nominated for Oscars as best actress (Blue Valentine) and best-supporting actress (Brokeback Mountain). Yet, when Michelle is not in character (and is allowed a retake, or two) - when she's just being Michelle - she is no better at lying than most people. Ms. Williams was either friends with Spacey (prior to the accusations) and/or she was surprised by the allegations against him. But what is not surprising, is that Michelle Williams now has significant contempt for Kevin Spacey.
A variation of Arm Crossing is the Double-Arm Grip. The President displays this most notably from 6:00 to 8:16. While less extreme in its beta emotional tone than arm crossing, it too is significant for defensiveness, emotional discomfort, and low confidence.
Despite his verbal language, Donald Trump's nonverbal behavior is guarded. No confident person grips each forearm in this manner. Try sitting at your own desk, while first talking and gesturing with your arms apart, palms-up. Next, speak the same words while gripping each forearm. Contrast how you feel in each position.
This forearm gripping is also yet another method to (partially) suppress excessive hand motion. Although primarily subconsciously controlled (with some edge-of-consciousness effect), in addition to the behavioral causes described above, this phenomenon is also another method to suppress and camouflage a drug side-effect and/or a medical movement/tremor/tremor-like disorder.
Yesterday, President Trump held a cabinet meeting prior to the US House vote on the tax bill. Many have inquired as to the significance of the President crossing his arms during the meeting. Over the past several months, Donald Trump has crossed his arms with increasing duration and frequency. To put this in historical-behavioral context, you'd be hard-pressed to find a single photo of any past US president crossing their arms during public events or meetings.
It's crucial to note that the President's hands are constantly hidden during his arm-crossing.
The video above is 18:04 in duration (1084 seconds) during which Donald Trump crossed his arms five times for a total of 325 seconds or 29.98% of the time.
Another intriguing detail of his behavior was demonstrated during the prayer - wherein he flexes/flicks/bends his wrists, with clasped hands twelve times. He also clasps and unclasps his hands multiple times. All this movement takes place in the space of 1 minute, 26 seconds. You'll note, even the videographer zoomed in on Trump's hands. Why can't the President maintain a prayer posture for 90 seconds?
During the entire remainder of the video, the president's hands are rarely free or isolated: 99% of the time, he was either clasping the other hand, grasping his left wrist/forearm with his right hand, grasping both wrists, etc. And similar to the prayer dynamic, his fists and/or clasped hands repeatedly raise up and down in a wrist flexing/extending motion.
You may recall during the recent FBI graduation ceremony prayer, President Trump looked up and opened his eyes (while everyone else bowed their heads and eyes closed). He also irreverently twisted/rotated his torso several times. During this graduation, his right hand was also in motion - as he patted his chest multiple times when the national anthem was played.
Now contrast these two videos. The one immediately above was from 26 February 2016 during the
campaign (approximately 22 months ago) as Donald Trump was mocking Marco Rubio.
Notice that then-candidate Trump had an easy time
drinking from a water bottle during a campaign event (0:36 - 1:16). If you look carefully, he is gripping the bottle with only a thumb and (at most) two fingers.
Now contrast this to the next video of Donald Trump taking a drink only days ago, on 18 December 2017. The contrast is striking.
Watching the slow, two-handed drinking posture of the President (at 6:50 and 17:01) is painful to see.
This cluster of behavior is due to both behavioral/psychological - as well as medical etiologies.
Crossing one's arms - with hands hidden is a classic signal of defensiveness-related anxiety. This Beta behavior telegraphs his insecurity and low confidence - which is why this body language is virtually historically nonexistent in past presidents during meetings or public appearances.
Yet the President's increasing frequency and duration of his hand dynamics strongly suggests a movement disorder or tremor/tremor-like phenomenon. Moreover, his excessive hand movements are highly out-of-context - such as during prayers - and when his hand is supposed to be held still over his heart during the National Anthem. It very much appears that his hands cannot be at rest without gripping, grasping, being braced, etc. Causes include a variety of medical conditions (most likely involving the Central Nervous System) as well as drug side-effects.
Summary: The president's increased duration and frequency of arm crossing project his growing beta emotions of anxiety, insecurity, and low confidence. In addition, with high probability, the President appears to be unable to hold his hands and arms still for more than a few seconds - crossing his arms, making fists, flexing/extending his wrists, grasping the opposite hand/wrist/arm, moving during solemn and out-of-context moments (prayers, national anthem) - all in an effort to disguise/camouflage a medical movement disorder and/or a drug side-effect.
Luis Elizondo was the head of the Advanced Aviation Threat Identification Program (AATIP) - which began in the US Defense Intelligence Agency in 2007 and operated until 2012. He resigned from his position at the U.S. Pentagon in October 2017 to protest both the government's secrecy as well as government's opposition to the AATIP. In his resignation letter (to U.S. Defense Secretary James Mattis) he stated that the program was not being taken seriously.
Mr. Elizondo was interviewed on Monday 18 December 2017 by CNN's Erin Burnett. A portion of that interview is included in the above video. What follows is a partial transcript of their dialog as well as partial nonverbal analysis of crucial portions of this interview.
ERIN BURNETT (beginning at 0:09): ... tell us what the purpose of the program was, and why it was so secretive.
LUIS
ELIZONDO: Sure, Ahum - the purpose of the program, ah, Advanced
Aerospace Threat Identification Program was really designed to do just
that - ahum - from a national security perspective - identify those
things that we see, whether, ah, we see them electro-optically, we see
them with radar, we see the ah, as ah, as eyewitness reports, ahum,
through a myriad of different ways and avenues that we receive the
information - and try to ascertain and determine if the information is a
potential threat to national security Ω - in a nutshell.
During 0:46, just after he says, "national security", Mr. Elizondo displays an expression of Bitter-Regret.
ERIN BURNETT: So - what did you find?
LUIS ELIZONDO: Well we found a lot - ahum Ω ∆
- I think ah, I think it's probably been a little bit
mischaracterized in some of the, the, th-, the social media you see ....
During 0:52, as he says "ahum" and for a split-second afterward, Mr. Elizondo again displays bitter regret Ω. Additionally, he closes his eyelids in a prolonged blink ∆ - which, when coupled with this mouth expression, is a regret amplifier.
It's profoundly important to stress that the Bitter-Regret expression is a nonverbal signal NOT seen DURING the telling of a lie.
Later in the interview:
LUIS
ELIZONDO: (beginning at 3:16): ... when, when I ran this program, I was
fundamentally looking at - my colleagues looking at two things:
ERIN BURNETT: Yeah?
LUIS ELIZONDO: 'What is it and how does it work?' Ahum, we have deliberately stayed away from going down the rabbit hole of 'Who's behind the wheel and what are their intentions?'
ERIN BURNETT: Yep
LUIS ELIZONDO:
Because that - th- a lot of people have a lot of f, feelings toward
that, and, and are very emotional about that, and what I wanted to do
was - to allow the data to speak for itself and then use that data to
inform leadership, senior DOD leadership, about the potential threat
that, that, these type of, of technologies pose to national security -
'specially over any type of controlled airspace that we might have - ahum§- so I'm not trying to be evasive, ah, in any way, or vague your a-, with your answer but -
During 3:52, Mr. Elizondo displays a "Tight-Lipped" configuration - particularly true on his upper lip - as he says, "ahum" and just before he says, "... so I'm not trying to be evasive, ah, in any way, or vague ...". This Tight-Lipped nonverbal signal transmits a hesitancy to disclose - telling us that Luis Elizondo was withholding some information. His momentary gaze down and to his right, along with his elevated medial eyebrows and central forehead contraction (CFC) and amplifies this thought-emotion.
Summary: Luis Elizondo's nonverbal, verbal, and paralanguage behavior shows he's clearly hesitant to reveal - and is indeed withholding some key findings of the Advanced Aviation Threat Identification Program.
Mr. Elizondo also has bitter-regret regarding either the ramifications of the discoveries made by the AATIP and/or the manner in which the government has dealt with these findings.
Luis Elizondo also believes he's being truthful and sincere when he implies that via the research performed by the AATIP, intelligent extraterrestrial craft have - and are continuing to visit Earth (This doesn't necessarily prove ETs have visited Earth - but Mr. Elizondo believes it to be so).
During two recent speeches in the last five weeks, President Trump has taken drinks of water using two hands. Why?
In a speech given earlier today, addressing issues of national security (included in the video above), the President displayed his two-handed drinking behavior during 6:50.
Notice how the President positions his fingers from each hand beneath the glass to stabilize its weight. This suggests he may have diminished grip strength.
President Trump also draws both his upper arms and forearms closer to his torso than would otherwise be required for normal drinking behavior. He also dramatically foreshortens his neck as he also flexes it. His lips also purse forward to meet the glass.
During 9:35 the President took a drink in a more conventional, one-handed style. Yet he still leaned forward, pulled his upper limbs inward, flexed his neck forward, and pursed his lips forward. He also stabilized the glass with a finger beneath it.
At 17:01, much as with the initial example, Donald Trump once again drinks in a two-handed fashion. This time he braces the bottom of the glass more firmly with his left hand.
Donald Trump first publicly demonstrated this behavior in this speech (immediately above) on 15 November 2017, after his return from his trip to Asia.
This example, similar to those above is seen at 11:41 in the second video.
Once again during 17:06 in the later video.
Summary: Many have inquired as to the body language significance of President Trump's two-handed drinking dynamic. As I am both a nonverbal expert as well as a physician, I can unequivocally say this behavior is NOT a body language phenomenon - rather, its etiology is medical.
In a general, possible causes of President Trump's two-handed drinking practice include disorders of the Central Nervous System (e.g., CVA, problems with proprioception, Trigeminal nerve lesion [CNS or PNS], etc.), the Peripheral Nervous System (e.g., peripheral neuropathy, etc.), or a pharmacologic (drug) side-effect (e.g., such as a psychomotor tremor secondary to stimulants, etc.). Any competent physician would recommend an immediate detailed neurologic evaluation.
The above image was captured on 11 December 2017 at the Thomas Fire (Ventura and Santa Barbara Counties). It is currently the third largest fire in California history. At the time of this writing, over 270,000 acres have burned (422 square miles/1,093 square kilometers). It is currently 40% contained.
We often tend to hold our hands on top of our heads when we feel a relatively sudden defeat or loss.
This is, in part, is a signal of emotional processing - wherein the intellectual mind knows what is happening/has just happened - but the ramifications of which the emotional mind is still grappling.
Prisoners of war (or those after police arrest), display identical nonverbal behavior - although, of course, they are forced. Such a posture of surrender not only serves as a method of lessening the likelihood of the captured physically retaliating and/or escaping - but it also psychologically engenders feelings of emotional and mental weakness.
This same body language MAP (Manipulator, Adaptor, Pacifier) is also common after losses (by players and fans alike) in sporting events around the World.
Intriguingly, not everyone will adopt this nonverbal display - however, those who do have higher levels of both Empathy and Sincerity relative to the average person.